A Brief Review on Titanium Dioxide
Disha L. Barad, Urvi J. Chotaliya, Nilesh K. Patel
Department of Pharmaceutical Quality Assurance, B.K. Mody Government Pharmacy College,
Polytechnic Campus, Near Aji Dem, Bhavnagar Road, Rajkot - 360003 Gujarat, India.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: amitvyas77@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Titanium Dioxide (TiO2) is widely used in food products and can be found in sauces, icings, and chewing gums as well as in personal care products such as pharmaceutical tablets and toothpaste. Tio2 particle added as a whitening agent to confectionary products, that is, chewing gum, candies, chocolate, and snacks. Titanium dioxide is found naturally in various crystal phases. It exists in different crystal structures. anatase, rutile, and brookite, or a mixture of these. The major routes of TiO2 NP exposure that have toxicological relevance in humans are inhalation, dermal, and oral exposure. for characterization of particle size, size distribution, crystallinity, and concentration of Tio2 particles were first extracted using an acid digestion method from food and separation, various analytical methods were applied. The present study focus on the analyzes qualitative and quantitative trace element by using some analytical methods. TiO2 levels of investigated foods were determined by UV Spectroscopy, Inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, UV-Visible diffuse reflectance, Raman spectroscopy, Electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction (XRD), Gas volumetry, Laser diffraction, Laser droppler electrophorosis, FT-Raman, Spectroscopic analysis.
KEYWORDS: Titanium dioxide, TiO2, Confectionery foods, ICP-OES, Myers’ optimized digestion procedure, Raman spectroscopy.
INTRODUCTION:
Titanium dioxide, titania (TiO2) White to slightly colored amorphous powder1. (TiO2) is a transition metal oxide2. that is insoluble in water and organic solvents3. TiO2 is a white, crystalline powder, it is commonly included in these products to obtain a brilliant white colour.4 One of the main differences between micro-TiO2 and nano-TiO2 is a much bigger active surface of nano-TiO2, a feature resulting in a higher absorption rate of UV and a greater photocatalytic activity. nano-TiO2 present in sunscreen cosmetics (with UV filter) enhances the creation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in skin cells, a phenomenon that may result in DNA damages and mutations and consequently induce the development of cancer diseases5. Assay: Titanium dioxide is an oxide of titanium. it contains not less than 98 percent TiO2, calculated concerning the dried substance6. Titanium dioxide (TiO2) is a traditional common pigment used for whitening and brightening in paints, cosmetics, sunscreens, foods, pharmaceutical pills, and toothpaste7. 70% of the produced TiO2 is used as a pigment. It is used not only in paints as pigments but also in plastics, paper, food, pharmaceuticals, toothpaste, and cosmetics8.
Titanium dioxide (TiO2) is a traditional common pigment used for whitening and brightening in paints, cosmetics, sunscreens, foods, pharmaceutical pills, and toothpaste.7 70% of the produced TiO2 is used as a pigment.
|
Figure:1 Titanium dioxide powder 9 |
Figure:2 Structure and formula of TiO210 |
It is used not only in paints as pigments but also in plastics, paper, food, pharmaceuticals, toothpaste, and cosmetics.8 As titanium dioxide has a low absorption rate, it is mostly excreted in the feces, suggesting that it does not present any toxicity concern.11 The industrial application of TiO2 in various foods, particularly in nonwhite foods, such as dried vegetables, soups, cheeses, sauces, and dietary supplements, is reported to enhance the whiteness and opacity of these commodities, and it also helps them resist discoloration. The current annual production of TiO2 is estimated at approximately 5.1 Mt throughout the world, and it is anticipated to continue increasing the use of TiO2, which has primarily been produced as nanosized particles for many years.12 Drug product is not completely pure, some amount of metal impurities are always present in pharmaceutical product may cause various toxicity when it will be administered.13,34
|
Different crystal structure |
|
|
|
1. Anatase |
|
|
|
2. Rutile |
|
|
|
3. Brookite |
Figure 3: Different crystal type15
Figure:4 The crystal structure of TiO217
2) Source of titanium dioxide:
Titanium dioxide is found naturally in various crystal phases. It exists in different crystal structures. anatase, rutile, and brookite, or a mixture of these. Rutile is the most stable form of TiO2 Anatase and brookite are stable at normal temperatures but slowly convert to rutile upon heating to temperatures above 550 and 750°C; respectively.13 only anatase and rutile are allowed as a food additive. Rutile and anatase TiO2 is the most commonly utilized because of its stability, high refractive index, and low light absorption.4
Table:1 Properties of the anatase and rutile phase of titanium dioxide16
|
Property |
Anatase |
Rutile |
|
Molecular weight (g/mol) |
79.88 |
79.88 |
|
Melting point (Celsius) |
1825 |
1825 |
|
Boiling point (Celsius) |
2500-3000 |
2500-3000 |
|
Specific gravity |
3.9 |
4.0 |
|
Light absorption (nm) |
λ≤385nm |
λ≤415nm |
|
Mohr’s hardness |
5.5 |
6.5 to 7 |
|
Refractive index |
2.55 |
2.75 |
|
Dielectric constant |
31 |
114 |
|
Crystal structure |
Tetragonal |
Tetragonal |
|
|
a = 3.784 c = 9.515 |
a = 4.5936 c = 2.9587 |
|
Ti-O bond length (Ĺ) |
1.937 (4) 1.965 (2) |
1.949 (4) 1.980 (2) |
3) Physical and chemical property of titanium dioxide
It occurs as a white or almost white fluffy powder, odorless and tasteless. It is practically insoluble in water and dilutes mineral acids. It dissolves slowly in hot sulphuric acid. It molecular weight of 79.9gm/mol, the boiling point of 2972°C, the melting point of 1843°C, and a relative density of 4.26gm/cm2 at 25°C. Titanium dioxide which has a chemical abstract service - No.13463-67-7, also known as titanium oxide, titanic acid anhydride, titania, titanic anhydride, or Ti white, is the naturally occurring oxide of Ti. Titanium exists in different forms combined with other minerals. The most common oxidation state of Ti is +4, but +3 and +2 states are also found in nature.14
4) Storage:
It is stored in well closed containers.6
5) Uses of tio2:
Titanium dioxide is used every day in our life. In food, Titanium dioxide has different uses. Its food-grade form is used as a colorant to enhance and brighten the colour of white foods such as dairy products, candy, icing, and as a powder that is used in bakeries such as on donuts. It is also used in different products that are used by adults and children such as drinks, ice cream, and chewing gum. These products are daily used by children. Titanium dioxide (TiO2) is a traditional common pigment used for whitening and brightening in paints, cosmetics, sunscreens, foods, pharmaceutical pills, and toothpaste.7 The TiO2 used in the market consists of both TiO2 nanoparticles and non-nanoparticles. Nanoparticles are defined as having a particle size with at least one dimension between 1–100 nm.18 Although TiO2 is permitted as an additive (E171) in food and pharmaceutical products we do not have reliable data on its absorption, distribution, excretion, and toxicity on oral exposure. TiO2 may also enter the environment, and while it exerts low acute toxicity to aquatic organisms, upon long-term exposure it induces a range of sub-lethal effects.14
Figure: 5 The additive commonly Found in toothpaste(19)
Figure: 6 TiO2 is commonly used as pigment to bring a bright and smooth White appearance to pastries or confe- Ctionary Or opacify yogurt or ice cream(20)
Figure: 7 Dunkin donuts removed nano titanium dioxide from their doughnuts in 201521
6) Levels of consumption:
The amount of TiO2 consumed in the USA daily was estimated at around 0.2–0.7mg of TiO2 per kg of body weight per day (mg/kg bw/d), while the UK and German populations consume around 1mg TiO2/kg BW/day. For example, the estimate of the median long-term exposure to titanium dioxide (E 171) ranges from 0.5 (upper limit 1.1mg/kg bw/d) for elderly adults to 1.4mg/kg bw/d (upper limit 3.2mg/kg bw/d) for children in the Netherlands, close to the estimate in Germany. In addition to food products, tablets such as medicine and food supplements contain TiO2 up to 3.6mg/g, resulting in a higher total daily intake of TiO2.2
7) Exposure route of titanium dioxide:
Food, cosmetics, and paints have the most common fine particles of TiO₂ effect in humans and the environment. TiO2 occurs in tissues of normal animals but only in trace amounts. There is no evidence of TiO2 being an essential element for human beings or animals. The TiO2 compound concentration in drinking water is generally low. A typical diet may contribute 300–400 μg/day.2
7.1) Inhalation exposure:
Inhalation is one of the major routes for TiO2NPs to gain entry into the human body in the workplace like manufacturing and processing. In the human body, when TiO2 NPs are translocated in the blood and they retain on the liver and lymphatic system, distributed to other organs and tissue, and eliminated out of the body. Titanium dioxide is "possibly carcinogenic to humans.14,33
Figure: 8 Particulate distribution of TiO2 particles by size through different regions of the respiratory tract22
7.2) Dermal exposure:
Dermal absorption of TiO2NPs through several consumer products, such as cosmetics and sunscreens, may contain TiO2NPs. The outer skin of human beings consists of a tough layer of stratum corneum (SC) that is difficult for inorganic particles to penetrate.14 Theoretically, only those materials with an appropriate Octanol/water partition coefficient and low molecular weight (˂ca.500) should penetrate the intact human skin through the SC. Cosmetics and sunscreens containing TiO2 are normally used on intact skin which is used as pigments more than 70% with fine particles 100 nm.22
7.3) Oral exposure:
TiO2NPs are also widely used for toothpaste, food colorants, medical capsules, and nutritional supplements. Therefore, oral exposure may occur during the use of such products. A recent study found that candies such as sweets, chocolate, and chewing gums, contained the highest amount of fine particles TiO2. TiO2 can have toxic effects when utilized as E171 in food manufacture especially at higher age due to accumulation in liver, spleen, and ovaries, and can lead to alteration in thyroid function, testosterone level, and increased inflammation level, and liver damage.22
8) Titanium dioxide application:
Figure: 9 Application of TiO223
Titanium dioxide in the form of nanoparticles (TiO2 NPS) has become a common additive in paints, plastics, personal care products (cosmetics, sunscreens), and food—as the additive E171. Nowadays, TiO2 NPs are one of the most manufactured nanomaterials in the world. Particles of size in the nanoscale have a higher surface-to-volume ratio, as compared to macro or micro-particles. This fact affects their properties, such as reactivity of surface area, the degree to which the NPS aggregate, or bioavailability. It is generally known that an increase in surface area accelerates the dissolution processes. Higher dissolution rates and smaller size of particles enhance their absorption through membranes, which leads to their deposition within tissues and organs after oral administration, while the insoluble material is mostly excreted with feces. As the dissolution rates achieved by TiO2 are very low, the cytotoxic effects caused by TiO2-NPs are more closely related to their size rather than due to metallic ions being released from the particles absorbed by cells.23,24 It is used not only in paints as pigments but also in plastics, paper, food, pharmaceuticals, toothpaste, and cosmetics.25,26
9) Analytical methods:
Many advanced techniques, including electron microscopy, spectroscopy, mass spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction (XRD), X-ray fluorescence (XRF), and light scattering, have been applied to characterize the physicochemical properties of TiO2 in consumer products. For qualitative and quantitative trace element analysis, inductively coupled plasma−mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) has been commonly used. One of the more recently developed methods for quantitation of food additives or toxic materials in food involves Raman spectroscopic methods. Raman method for use as a quick and simple technique for the quantitative determination of TiO2 in complex matrices. The TiO2 concentration determined by ICP-MS was used as a reference value to evaluate the accuracy of the Raman technique.27 Analytical methods are used to identify and quantify these impurities to the trace level at a given interim limit.28,35,36
Analytical methods:
1. Qualitative analysis:
a. Identification:
b. General Test:
i
Appearance of Solution
ii
Acidity or Alkalinity
iii
Water-soluble substance
iv
Arsenic
v
Barium
vi
Heavy metals
vii
Iron
c. Morphological analysis:
i
Electron microscopy
ii
XRD (X-ray diffraction)
iii
DRIFTS (Diffuse
reflectance infrared fourier transfom spectroscopy)
iv
Gas volumetry
v
Laser diffraction
vi
FT – Raman
vii
Spectroscopic analysis
2. Quantitative analysis:
a. Assay method
b. UV spectroscopy
c. ICP-OES (Inductivity coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy)
d. XPS analysis (X-Ray photoelectron spectroscopy)
e. UV–VISIBLE DR (Ultra violet visible diffuse reflectance)
f. Raman spectroscopy
I) Sample:
Sample products, including a coffee cream, cookie, yogurt snack, hard candy, and chewy candy, were tested and reported in this study. All confectionery foods were obtained from retail markets. The samples could be categorized into four groups, which were candies, chewing gums, chocolates, and snacks. Certain products that had a label bearing TiO2 as an ingredient were preferentially selected for the experimental samples, but some collected samples did not have TiO2 listed as an ingredient.12
II) TiO2 particle extraction from food products:
Sample products selected in this study contain various food ingredients or organic compounds. TiO2-containing products were digested in HNO3. Approximately 100−200mg of each sample and 2 mL of nitric acid were heated at 180°C for 3 min using a Mars 6 microwave digestion system. Some samples, such as candy, which has a very low concentration of TiO2 and contains various food color additives, needed an additional pre-extraction procedure. Approximately 1g of candy samples was first dissolved in a 5mL mixture solution containing H2O2/HNO3 (10:0.1, v/v) at 80°C. After the solid food was dissolved, the samples were centrifuged at 7000g for 10 min, and the precipitate only was acid digested in 2mL of nitric acid at 180°C for 3 min. Digested solutions were then transferred into 15 mL tubes and centrifuged at 7000g for 10min. After centrifugation, extracted particles were rinsed with ultrapure water and acetone three times. For further analysis, the extracted particles were dispersed in ethanol and stored at room temperature.27
III) Separation of TiO2 nanoparticles:
TiO2 nanoparticles were isolated from the food commodities to observe TEM images by placing approximately 100mg of ground samples in a 15ml conical glass tube. A 3ml digestion solution made by mixing 10ml of hydrogen peroxide with 0.5ml of nitric acid was poured into the tube, which was then heated in a dry block bath at 120°C for 2–3 hours until the final volume nearly reached 2ml. After cooling at room temperature, the remaining sample was transferred into a 2ml centrifuge tube and ultrasonicated for 1 min. The samples were centrifuged at 10,000g for 20 min using a microcentrifuge to obtain whitish particles. The precipitated particles were collected and resuspended in 2ml ethanol. This purification process was repeated twice to acquire pure particles that were used for the TEM experiment.12
9.1) Qualitative analysis:
9.1.1) Identification:
when strongly heated it becomes pale yellow the colour is discharged on cooling. Add 10ml of sulphuric acid and boil gently until clear, cool, add slowly 30ml of a 25 percent v/v solution of sulphuric acid and dilute with water to 100ml (solution A). To 0.5g add 5g of anhydrous sodium sulphate and 10ml of water and mix. To 5ml of solution A add 0.1ml of strong hydrogen peroxide solution; an orange-red colour is produced. To 5 ml of solution, A add 0.5g of zinc, in granules; after 45 minute a violet-blue color is produced add 10ml of sulphuric acid. Boil gently until clear, cool, add slowly 40 ml of cooled sulphuric acid (25percent), cool again and dilute with water to 100.0ml (solution B). To 300g of zinc, in granules, add 300ml of a 2 percent w/v solution of mercuric nitrate and 2ml of nitric acid, shake for 10 minutes and wash with water. Pass through the column; at a rate of about 3ml per minute, 100ml of 1 M sulphuric acid followed by 100ml of water, ensuring that the amalgam is covered with liquid throughout Pack the zinc amalgam into a glass tube (400mm x 20mm) fitted with a tap and a filter plate Pass slowly through the column, at a rate of about 3ml per minute, 200ml of 0.5 M sulphuric acid followed by 100ml of water Collect the combined eluates in a 500ml conical flask containing 50 ml of a 15 percent w/v solution of ferric ammonium sulphate in sulphuric acid (25 percent) And titrate immediately with 0.1 M ceric ammonium nitrate using ferroin solution as indicator until a greenish colour is obtained (n, ml) Pass slowly through the column 100ml of 0.5 M sulphuric acid followed by 20.0ml of solution B wash with 100ml of 0.5 M sulphuric acid followed by 100ml of water Collect the combined eluates in a 500ml conical flask containing 50ml of a 15 percent w/v solution of ferric ammonium sulphate in sulphuric acid (25 percent) Rinse the lower end of the column with water and titrate immediately with 0.1M ceric ammonium nitrate using ferroin solution as indicator , until a greenish colour is obtained.30
9.1.2) General tests6:
9.1.2.1) Appearance of solution.
Solution A is not more opalescent than opalescence standard OS2 and colourless.
9.1.2.2) Acidity or alkalinity.
Shake 5.0g with 50ml of carbon dioxide-free water for 5 minutes and centrifuge until a clear soluton is obtained To 10ml of the solution add 0.1ml of bromothymol blue solution. No more than 1.0ml of either 0.01M hydrochloric acid or 0.01M sodium hydroxide is required to change the color of the solution.
9.1.2.3) Water-soluble substances:
Not more than 0.5percent, determined by the following method. Boil 10.0g for 5 minutes with 150ml of water containing 0.5g of ammonium sulphate. Cool, dilute to 200ml with water, and filter until a clear solution is obtained. Evaporate 100ml of the filtrate to dryness ignite and weigh.
9.1.2.4) Arsenic:
To 0.2g in a 100ml Kjeldahl flask, add 2g of anhydrous sodium sulphate. 7ml of sulphuric acid and 5ml of nitric acid, Heat gently until a clear solution is obtained, cool. add 10ml of water, cool again, and add 5g of hydraine reducing mixture and 10ml of hydrochloric acid. Immediately attach an air condenser and distill into 15 ml of cooled water until a total volume of 30ml is obtained. Rinse the condenser with 5ml of water and dilute the combined distillate and rinse to 40ml with water. 20ml of the resulting solution complies with the limit test for arsenic. Use a mixture of 0.5ml of arsenic standard solution (1ppm as) and 24.5ml of water to prepare the standard (5ppm).
9.1.2.5) Barium:
Shake 20.0g with 30ml of hydrochloric acid, add 100ml of distilled water, and boil. Filter while hot through a. hardened filter paper until a clear filtrate is obtained. Wash the filter with 60ml of distilled water and dilute the combined filtrate and washings to 200ml with distilled water. To 10ml of this solution add 1ml of 1 M sulphuric acid. After 30 minutes. any opalescence is not more intense than that of a mixture of 10ml of the test solution and 1ml of distilled water.
9.1.2.6) Heavy metals:
Dilute 10ml of the solution prepared in the test for Barium to 20ml with water. 12ml of the solution complies with the limit test for heavy metals, Method D (20ppm), using 10ml of lead standard solution (1ppm Pb).
9.1.2.7) Iron:
To 8ml of solution A, add 4ml of water, mix and add 0.05ml of bromine water, allow to stand for 5 minutes, remove the excess of bromine with a current of air, and add 3ml of potassium thiocyanate solution. Any colour in the solution is not more intense than that in a standard prepared at the same time and in the same manner using a mixture of 4ml of e iron standard solution (2ppm Fe) and 8ml of a 20 percent w/v solution of sulphuric acid (200ppm). Calculate the percentage content of TiO2 from the expression 3.99(n1-n2)/w. Where, w is the weight, in g, of the substance under examination used in the preparation of solution A.
9.2) Morphological analysis:
9.2.1) Electron microscopy analysis:
The powder was dispersed in ethanol (1.5mg/ml), Then the suspension was sonicated for 10 minutes and one drop of 10μL was deposited on the surface of a copper grid covered with a thin holey carbon film. To obtain a size distribution of primary particles, at least 300 particles of each sample were identified on at least 7 different locations on the grid and analysed using ImageJ software. The size of primary particles was measured on isolated particles and inside the aggregates or agglomerates using the diffraction contrast. The equivalent circle diameter (ECD) corresponding to the diameter of a circle with an equivalent area was calculated, given the sphere-like shape of particles.30
9.2.2) XRD (X-RAY diffraction):
Crystalline structures of raw powder samples were characterized by XRD working at Cu Kα1 radiation wavelength. Each sample was scanned from 20° to 80°. XRD patterns were analyzed with Diffract plus Eva software to assign the diffraction peaks to the different crystalline phases of TiO2.31
9.2.3) DRIFTS (Diffuse reflectance infrared fourier transform spectroscopy):
The functional groups at the surface of particles were probed by infrared spectroscopy. The spectra were recorded in diffuse reflectance. Powder samples were poured into the sample cell and the average plane of the powder was leveled by removing the excess with a glass plate. Once the sample support was introduced in the praying mantis, spectra were recorded with a spectral resolution of 4 cm-1 every 5 minutes for 2h, the time required to dehydrate the sample under flushing with dried air. The final relative humidity around the sample was measured to be lower than 1% at 298 K. The last averaged 800 scans are presented in this paper and plotted as log (Rsample/Rref) where Rsample and Rref are the diffuse single-beam reflectance of the sample and the reference, respectively.31
9.2.4) Gas volumetry:
The specific surface areas of TiO2 samples were determined by multipoint Brunauer– Emmett–Teller treatment (BET method) from the volumetric adsorption isotherms at 77 K of nitrogen gas using a Micromeritics TriStar II 3020 Physisorption Analyzer. All samples were degassed under primary vacuum before the experiment, except for P25 which was additionally heated at 70°C for one hour.31
9.2.5) Laser diffraction:
A laser diffraction particle size analyzer was used to determine the volume-based size distribution of TiO2 dispersions in the range 0.01µm – 5000µm, for various pH values at room temperature. The instrument is composed of two light sources (a 655nm laser diode and a 405nm light-emitting diode), a sample handling system and an array of high-quality photodiodes to detect the scattered light over a wide range of angles. The scattered light collected on the detectors is used to calculate the volume-based size distribution of the sample using the single scattering Mie theory. Experiments were performed using the intern cuvette (volume 15mL) filled with the dispersion medium (deionized water adjusted with HCl/NaOH at the desired pH). Depending on pH, 1 to 5mL of the TiO2 dispersions was introduced in the cell to reach an obscuration percentage ranging from 3 and 5% (i.e., a transmittance value around 95-97% for both the blue LED beam and the red laser beam). The alignment was performed before each measurement and data acquisition times were set as default. TiO2 refractive index was fixed at 2.40 (655nm) and 2.70 (405 nm) for E171, and 2.45 (655nm) and 2.76 (405nm) for P25, based on the anatase/rutile ratio and the refractive indices of pure crystalline phases. The imaginary 7 part was fixed at 0 at both wavelengths. The particle size is reported as a volume equivalent sphere diameter. Due to the high tendency of TiO2 to agglomerate in aqueous suspensions, this particle size refers to agglomerates of TiO2, in contrast to the particle size distribution obtained by TEM which is related to the primary particles.31
9.2.6) Laser droppler electrophoresis:
Zeta potentials were determined by Laser Doppler Electrophoresis (also called electrophoretic light scattering) with a Zetasizer Nano ZS instrument equipped with a 633nm He-Ne laser, measuring the scattered light at an angle of 173°. Experiments were performed at 37°C with and withoutNaCl (4.10-2molL-1) added to the previously prepared dispersions. For each sample, after an equilibration time of 2 minutes to reach 37°C, three electrophoretic mobility measurements (each one including 5 runs of 18 seconds) were performed to ensure repeatability. For easier comparison with other published data, our measurements were converted into zeta potential values, using Henry's equation and applying Smoluchowski approximation.31
9.2.7) FT – Raman:
The inelastic Raman vibrational spectra of TiO2 samples were recorded with a Fourier transform spectrometer combined with the software OPUS. The Raman signals were excited by focusing a near-infrared beam at 1064 nm on an area of around 100x100µm˛ with a power of 150mW. The system was equipped with a 143 K cooled InGaAs detector. The cell was filled with TiO2 powder and covered by a glass slide then positioned at the focal plane. One hundred scans were accumulated to record the backscattered spectra with a spectral resolution of 4 cm-1 at room conditions. Spectra are given with precision in 8 wavenumbers (in vacuum) better than 0.1 cm-1.31
9.2.8) Spectroscopic analysis:
The crystal structure of TiO2 powders was determined by XRD with a Cu Kα source (Siemens D5000) and an aluminum holder. Each sample was scanned at 2θ values from 20° to 60° to detect the characteristic TiO2 peaks. Semiquantitative analysis of the crystalline phases (e.g., the ratio of anatase to rutile) was calculated for appropriate samples using PANalytical High Score Plus software (based on the Rietveld method). Raman spectroscopy was performed using a 532nm laser on a custom instrument with a maximal power of 100mW, a spatial resolution of <1μm, and a spectral resolution of ∼1 cm−1. Multiple TiO2 particles (or particle aggregates) were analyzed to obtain crystal structure information representative of the entire sample.30
9.3) Quantitative:
9.3.1) UV Spectroscopy11, 37:
The TiO2 standard for ICP analysis was diluted with 10% sulfuric acid to make a stock solution at 100mg L-1 concentration. A calibration curve was prepared with 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, 1, 2, 5, and 10mg l-1 concentrations, obtained by serially diluting the stock solution. Samples of size 500mg for three products including candy, chewing gum, and chocolate that had been confirmed not to contain TiO2 were fortified with approximately 5mg and 10mg TiO2 reference material in rutile crystalline form to perform a recovery study. The spiked samples were then digested via the previously described method using sulfuric acid and digestion.
Titanium calibration solutions:
Based on a spectrophotometric procedure, two calibration curves for low and high concentrations of TiO2 (IV) were prepared. Solutions of 0, 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, and 12mg/L for low concentrations, and 0, 20, 40, and 60mg/L for high concentrations were prepared by spiking the appropriate volumes of the stock 1000mg/L solution into 100ml beakers, following the steps in Myers’ optimized digestion procedure.
The corresponding TiO2 concentrations were calculated from the corresponding molecular weight ratio of TiO2 to Ti. Similar calibration curves were also established from directly weighing 0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 10 mg of TiO2 for low concentrations and 0, 2, 4, and 6mg of TiO2 for high concentrations, this was done to confirm the reproducibility of the calibration curves using either solid TiO2 standards or Ti aqueous stock solutions from a different source.
Preparation of foodstuffs samples solutions:
Food samples was treated according to Myers’ optimized procedure in duplicates.
Myers’ optimized digestion procedure:
Duplicate accurate maximum weight close to 0.5000g sample in 100ml Pyrex beakers were digested with, 13 mL of 18 M H2SO4, 3.5g K2SO4, and 0.40g CuSO4 at 3100C on a hot plate for one hour and a half, then adding 4.0ml concentrated HNO3, and 4.0ml concentrated HCl gradually to the hot solution for another half an hour, where beakers were covered by watch-glasses (Myers., et al used Kjeldahl digestion without HCl or HNO3). Solutions were left to cool down for 30 minutes, where samples had blue to blue-green color (catalyst color), indicating the complete digestion, followed by adding 10 mL of 30% H2O2. Finally, volume is brought up to 100 mL with deionized water in 100ml volumetric flasks. Samples were measured spectrophotometrically at 410 nm in a 1cm quartz cuvette.
RESULT:
TiO2 calibration curves:
Two linear TiO2 calibration curves were established for low and high range concentrations. The range was chosen based on the most gathered foodstuffs items which indicated products free from TiO2 or those with expected small amounts (low concentrations ‘calibration curve), while other products indicated the addition of considerable amounts of TiO2 (calibration curve for higher concentrations). The obtained calibration equation was y = 0.0098x+ 0.0001 (Figure 1), and y = 0.0101x + 0.0002 for low and high concentrations, respectively.
Percent recovery experiment:
Samples of titanium dioxide (0.20–6.0mg) were suspended in 15% gelatine (organic material that is devoid from TiO2) solution at 50°C which was then cooled to room temperature to form solid gelatine blocks (Lomer et al., 2000), then the resulted in solid blocks were digested and analyzed as mentioned above. TiO2 concentration results are compared with the same TiO2 concentrations in the non-gelatine matrix.
Figure:10) Spectrophotometric linear calibration curve of TiO2 for (a) low concentrations and (b) high concentrations of TiO212
Result:
Percent recovery experiment:
The percent mean recovery of TiO2 from gelatine spiked samples was 95.74% ± 1.06% (Figure 2), which showed the applicability of the method to foodstuffs with high yield.
Figure: 11) Recovery of tio2 in control samples suspended in gelatin. the % recovery = (the calibration slope ± standard deviation of slope) × 100%. the solid line presented by the equation (y = x) represents the 100% recovery
Standard addition method:
The standard addition method was applied to one of the samples to evaluate the matrix effect and accuracy of external calibration curves (Thompson and Ellison, 2005). Shampart powder juice with peach flavour was chosen. The sample was homogenized into a fine powder using a grinder, where five portions of 0.08g of powder juice in Pyrex beakers were spiked with 0, 2, 4, 6, and 8 mg/L, respectively as Ti from the 1000mg/L stock solution (corresponding TiO2 concentrations were calculated), then digested, and analyzed as above. Another 0.15g portion of the Shampart powder juice was digested and analyzed for its TiO2 content according to the prescribed procedure above using the external calibration curves.
Result:
Standard addition:
The standard addition calibration equation for the spiked 0.08g Shampart juice portions was y = 0.0089x + 0.0603 with R2 = 0.9999. The standard addition curve gave an intercept of 6.775mg/L (Figure 3) which represents the TiO2 concentration in the original sample as 8.469 mg/g or 0.847%. The external calibration curve result for the 0.15g sham part juice showed 11.90mg/L TiO2 concentration corresponding to 0.1172 absorbance that represents the TiO2 concentration in the original sample as 8.320mg/g or 0.832%. The percentage relative error was -1.77% (assuming the standard addition result as the true value) indicating the accuracy of the external calibration curves, and the negligible effect of matrix interferences.
9.3.2) ICP-OES measurement (Inductivity coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy):
In case Palestine ministry of health (PMOH) uses the ICP-OES instrument with following steps.
1) Weight 5grams of the food sample (weight depends on the food type).
2) 10ml of concentrated sulfuric acid Added to the sample in a borosilicate glass tube and heated up to 250C with digested for 1 hour.
3) Samples were cooled at room temperature.
4) Transferred cooled sample into 50ml polypropylene centrifuge tube and the borosilicate glass tube was thoroughly rinsed with 10% sulfuric acid and rinsing was added to the polypropylene tube.
5) If precipitate formed, the sample was either centrifuged at 3000rpm for 5min and the resulting supernatant fraction was analyzed by ICP-OES.
6) A blank sample, using 10ml of concentrated sulfuric acid without sample, was similarly prepared for every 10 samples
7) The digested sample volume was made up to 40ml with 10% sulfuric acid, giving a final acid concentration of 32.5%.
In case using (Birzeit University) using ICP -OES instrument with following steps
1. Weigh 5grams of the food sample (weight depends on the food type).
2. Burn at 600C until completed.
3. Digest ash with 10% concentrated sulfuric acid H2SO4.
4. Transfer digested to 50ml volumetric flask and completed volume with Milli Q water.
5. Filtered 10ml from the volumetric flask (microfiltration 0.45-micrometer nylon syringe filter).
6. Run on ICP-OES.14
9.3.3) XPS analysis of TiO2 powders:
TiO2 samples were prepared by pressing 100mg of the powder into a pellet then deposited on the sample holder. The samples were electrically isolated from the holder to limit possible uncompensated charge effects. Charge compensation was achieved using a low-energy electron flow gun. Survey spectra (Pass Energy 160 eV) and scans of the region of interest (Pass Energy 20 eV) focused on the detected elements were recorded. The data were treated with Casa XPS software (Neal Fairley, Copyright© 2005 Casa Software Ltd, 2005), using Shirley backgrounds and Gaussian-Lorenzian (70-30 ratio) function to account for the different components. The estimated depth of analysis is approximately 6.6 nm as determined from the inelastic mean free path of electron scattering for TiO2. The adventitious carbon peak was used for calibration (285 eV).31
9.3.4) Ultraviolet-visible light diffuse reflectance measurement (UV-VISIBLE DR):
UV−vis DR spectra were obtained on a Lambda 18 instrument (Perkin-Elmer) with a 150mm integrating sphere accessory. Powder samples were pressed into disks, analyzed for reflectance, and then converted to absorbance.30
9.3.5) Photocatalytic activity measurement:
The presence or absence of photocatalytic activity of the samples was measured using a simulated solar reactor consisting of a 300 W xenon arc lamp. The spectrum was filtered through a standard air mass filter (AM 1.5 Global) to simulate sunlight irradiance at ground level with the sun at a zenith angle of 48.2°. Actinometric measurements using 2-nitrobenzaldehyde yielded a flux of (6.7±1.0) × 1015 photons cm−2 s −1. Acid green 25, an anionic dye, was used as a probe compound to test the photocatalytic activity of the TiO2 powders. The concentration was measured using UV−vis at an absorption peak of 625nm. TiO2 (0.1 mg/L) and an acid green solution (60mg/L, 96.4μM) were added to a 160 mL double-walled reactor and mixed for 1 h in the dark before being tested. Minimal adsorption was observed for all samples.30
9.3.6) Raman spectroscopy:
Raman scattering measurements were performed using a LabRam HR Raman spectrometer equipped with a 633 nm excitation laser and a 10X objective. The spatial resolution and laser spot diameter were approximately 1.5µm and 3.0µm, respectively. The Raman spectra were obtained with a 100µm slit aperture with a 5 s acquisition time. LabSpec 6.4 software was used for Raman data acquisition and analysis. The TiO2 calibration curve was developed with six independent TiO2 working standards with 0.07-2.3 wt%. The calibration standard powders were prepared by mixing anatase TiO2 particles (food and pharmaceutical grade) with Al2O3. In the case of food samples, particles were extracted by acid digestion described previously. Dried particles were mixed with Al2O3, where the amount of Al2O3 was dependent on the original amount of each sample digested (100-200mg). In the case of RS06, multiple samples were digested to prepare one Raman sample due to low TiO2 concentration, and the extracted TiO2 was concentrated almost 20-fold while mixed with Al2O3. The mass of extracted samples and Al2O3 were recorded. Well, mixed standards or samples were placed onto a glass slide and pressed with another slide to make a flat surface. A flat surface facilitated focusing and moving the stage quickly. To improve the accuracy of quantitative analysis, more than fifteen discrete locations in each sample were selected under the Raman microscope by controlling the x-y axis and scanned in the range of 50-800 cm-1. All experiments were performed in triplicate with independent samples and average concentration reported.27
CONCLUSION:
X-ray diffraction, ICP-OES, and UV spectroscopy were used to evaluate the content, morphological, qualitative, and quantitative features of TiO2 nanoparticles found in confectionary foods. The daily consumption of TiO2 in the United States is estimated to be between 0.2 and 0.7 mg per kg of body weight per day (mg/kg bw/d), but the UK and German populations ingest around 1 mg TiO2/kg BW/day. Children (3–9 years) and teenagers (10–17 years) are the biggest consumers of TiO2, regardless of the exposure scenario or methodological choices. In addition to food products, tablets containing TiO2 up to 3.6 mg/g, such as medicine and dietary supplements, result in a higher total daily intake of TiO2.
REFERENCE:
1. Titanium Dioxide. 2021; 12(August). Available on https://www.degruyter.com/database/IUPAC/entry/iupac.compound.26042/html.
2. Muriel M, Bernard H. Titanium Dioxide As A Food Additive. Intech Open Science. 2017; July (26) 10.5772/intechopen.68883
(https://www.intechopen.com/books/application-of-titaniumdioxide/titanium-dioxide-as-food-additive).
3. Verleysen E, Waegeneers N. et al. Physicochemical Characterization of the Pristine E171 Food Additive by Standardized and Validated Methods. Nanomaterials. 2020; 10: 592.
4. Adriana-Berenice PV, Alberto PB, et al. Toxic effect of titanium dioxide nanoparticles on human mesenchymal stem cells. Molecular & Cellular Toxicology. 2020; 16: 321–330.
5. Bogdan J, Jackowska-Tracz A, et al. Chances and limitations of nanosized titanium dioxide practical application in view of its physicochemical properties. Nanoscale Research Letters. (2015); 10: 57.
6. G.R. Chatwal. Pharmaceutical Chemistry – Inorganic Vol – I. Himalaya Publishing House, New Delhi. 2019; 5: 191.
7. Zhangjian Chen, Di Zhou. Hepatotoxicity and the role of the gut-liver axis in rats after oral administration of titanium dioxide nanoparticles. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2019; Dec 27; 16(1):48.
8. Sungur S, Kaya P, et al. Determination of titanium dioxide nanoparticles used in various foods. Food Addit Contam Part B Surveill. 2020; Dec13(4): 260-267.
9. Titanium Dioxide Powder. 2021; 15(August). Available on https://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hellonaturalliving.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2018%2F03%2Ftitanium-dioxide-powder.jpg&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hellonaturalliving.com%2Ftitanium-dioxide-is-it-safe-or-should-you-avoid-it%2F&tbnid=ZMfVn7ArUR5RbM&vet=1&docid=MzoTQrAHKd24oM&w=800&h=496&itg=1&hl=en-US&source=sh%2Fx%2Fim
10. Structure and Formula of TiO2. 2021; 17(August). Available on https://images.app.goo.gl/SaNxFpMSF9KdKDHR9.
11. Dudefoi W, Terrisse H. Criteria to define a more relevant reference sample of titanium dioxide in the context of food a multiscale approach. Food Additives Contaminants Part A Chem Anal Control Expo Risk Assess. 2017; May34(5): 653-665.
12. Kim N., Kim C., et al., “Determination and Identification of Titanium Dioxide Nanoparticles in Confectionery Foods, Marketed in South Korea, Using Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry and Transmission Electron Microscopy.”, Food Additive Contaminants Part A Chem Anal Control Expo Risk Assess, 2018 Jul; 35(7):1238-1246.
13. Ashok B. Patel, Avadhi R. Bundheliya, Amitkumar J. Vyas, Nilesh K. Patel, Ajay I. Patel, Arvind N. Lumbhani. A Review on Metal Impurities in Pharmaceuticals. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis. 2021; 11(3):212-2.
14. Dr Basma damiri, Dr Abdel Fattah R. Hasan PhD. Evalution Of Titanium Dioxide Level in Certain Traditional Food in The West BanK. An Najah National University Faculty of Graduates Studies, 2018 oct.
15. Bischoff NS de Kok, TM Sijm DTHM. Possible Adverse Effects of Food Additive E171 (Titanium Dioxide) Related to Particle Specific Human Toxicity Including the Immune System. International Journal of Molecular Sciences. 2020 Dec; 28; 22(1):207.
16. Pardon N., Omobola O., “Synthetic Method of Titanium Dioxide Nanoparticles: A Review.”, Intech Open 2018 Nov; 5 doi: 10.5772/intechopen.75425.
17. The crystal structure of TiO2. 2021; 18(August). Available on https://images.app.goo.gl/4FrfCtffbj1zSredA
18. Christianto P, PhD. Estimation Of Ingested Nano-Titanium Dioxide Among Healthy Adults and Its Association with Intestinal Permeability and Inflammation. B.S. Monash University Malaysia (2014) And M.S. University of Massachusetts Lowell 2016.
19. The additive is commonly found in Toothpaste. 2021; 1(September). Available on https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjOhKuMkJz0AhViyzgGHfPFAiwQFnoECAIQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.news.com.au%2Flifestyle%2Ffood%2Ffood-additive-used-in-lollies-gum-toothpaste-under-review-amid-safety-concerns%2Fnews-story%2F70786559b27c40015d10e00ff0d56a95&usg=AOvVaw01ppD1RbqKbpeP7S151bFR .
20. TiO2 is commonly used as a pigment to bring a bright and smooth white appearance to pastries or confectionary or opacify yogurt or ice cream 2021; 22(August). Available on https://tdma.info/titanium-dioxide-in-food/.
21. Dunkin donuts removed nano titanium dioxide from their doughnuts in 2015. 2021; 5(September). Available on https://images.app.goo.gl/kZthqYYmKPAcpM9Z7.
22. Shi H, Magaye R, et al. Titanium dioxide nanoparticles: a review of current toxicological data. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2013; (10) 15.
23. Musial J Krakowiak R, Mlynarczyk DT, et al. Titanium Dioxide Nanoparticles in Food and Personal Care Products-What Do We Know about Their Safety? Nanomaterials (Basel). 2020; 10(6):1110.
24. Reni Mullukattil Lukose. Toxic Effect of Nanoparticles of Metals (Pb, Cd, Ag, Mn, Fe and Zn) and Metal Oxides (ZnO, CuO, TiO2 and CeO2) in Human Body. Asian J. Research Chem. 6(12): December 2013; Page 1179-1182.
25. Avnish Kumar Arora, Vivek Sheel Jaswal, Renu Bala. Metal/Mixed Metal Oxides and their Applications as Catalyst: A Review. Asian J. Research Chem. 2018; 11(6):893-899.
26. Muhammad Adnan Younis, Iftikhar Hussain Bukhari, Qaisar Abbas, Neelam Bin Talib, Sana Shaukat. Synthesis, importance and applications of metal oxide nanomaterials. Int. J. Tech. 2018; 8(2): 49-57.
27. Ruud J.B, Peters Greet van Bemmel, et al. Characterisation of titanium dioxide nanoparticles in food products: Analytical methods to define nanoparticles. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2014 jun 16; 62, 27:6285–6293.
28. Vyas, Amitkumar J., et al. "A review on carcinogenic impurities found in marketed drugs and strategies for its determination by analytical methods." Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis 11.2 (2021): 159-169.
29. Jin-Hee Lim, Dongryeoul Bae. Titanium Dioxide in Food Products: Quantitative Analysis Using ICP MS and Raman Spectroscopy. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2018; 66 (51):13533-13540.
30. Indian Pharmacopoeia, the government of India, Ministry of health and family Welfare; 7th EDN; the Indian Pharmacopoeia Commission, Ghaziabad, 2007, Volume II, pp 1186-1187.
31. Yu Yang, Kyle Doudrick. Characterization of Food-Grade Titanium Dioxide: The Presence of Nanosized Particles. Environmental Science & Technology. 2014; 48, 11: 6391–6400.
32. Sharif H.A, Rasha, et al. Titanium dioxide content in foodstuffs from the Jordanian market: Spectrophotometric evaluation of TiO2 nanoparticles. International Food Research Journal. 2015; 22(3): 1024-1029.
33. Patel DV, et al. Quality improvement methodologies in pharmaceutical manufacturing. Asian Journal of Management. 2010; 1(1):01-03.
34. Patel AB, Asnani AH, et al. A brief review on genotoxic impurities in pharmaceuticals. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Research. 2021; 11(3):187-193.
35. Rani SG, et al. Glimepiride: A review of analytical methods. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis. 2014; 4(4):178-182.
36. Phadtare DG, et al. A brief review on quality by design and process analytical technology. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis. 2016; 6(2):122-130.
37. Sahoo CK, et al. Validation of analytical procedure- A Review. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis. 2018; 8(2):109-116.
Received on 12.02.2022 Modified on 06.04.2022
Accepted on 09.05.2022 ©Asian Pharma Press All Right Reserved
Asian J. Pharm. Ana. 2022; 12(3):187-196.
DOI: 10.52711/2231-5675.2022.00032